Supply Chain Secrets
The Supply Chain Secrets Podcast cuts through the noise to bring you real, unfiltered insights from the front lines of global logistics. Whether you’re a shipper, NVO, carrier, or just someone who needs to stay ahead of market shifts, we deliver analysis and hard-hitting conversations that actually matter. Visit nyshex.com/podcast to register to attend live!
Supply Chain Secrets
Rates in Freefall, Capacity Crunch, and What’s Next After Golden Week
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of Supply Chain Secrets, Caroline Weaver and Lars Jensen break down the latest volatility in container shipping. Asia–Europe rates continue their seasonal slide, while the Pacific faces a dramatic collapse in demand just as carriers push blank sailings.
Lars explains why the gap between quoted and paid spot rates matters, why blank sailings may slow—but not stop—rate erosion, and how Golden Week timing is shaping strategy.
The conversation also covers the looming U.S.–China tariff pause deadline, MEPC decarbonization politics, and CMA-CGM’s latest move in intermodal rail.
Hi everyone. Thanks for tuning in to the Supply Chain Secrets podcast. I'm your co-host, Caroline Weaver, and with me is Lars Jensen. Lars, how are you doing?
SPEAKER_02I'm doing great. Thanks. Calling in from the wonderful city of Busan in South Korea.
SPEAKER_01Oh, must be pretty late there for you. Well, we're approaching 10 p.m., but it's all good. Truly committed to being an excellent podcast host. Appreciate you staying on late. All right, let's jump into it. So let's start off with rates. Where are we at with things?
SPEAKER_02Uh if we take the non-event that would point to the Asia Europe, yes, it definitely went down. That is expected. We are still in the throes of the seasonal drawdown. So not much to comment on there, at least for not for now. What is much more interesting to watch is the quoted rates for once over on the Pacific, where the SCFI, I think a collapse would be the correct term here. I mean, we saw a about roughly a 30% week and week decline. It's not the first time in world history we have seen that decline, but it is a very, very stark decline. The increases we had seen for three consecutive weeks are all gone and more. This was a very, very rapid reversal. But there is another element I find even more interesting because one thing are the quoted rates from the SCFI, if I look at the NIFI rates, these spot rates that are actually being paid. And as we have discussed before, there is a lag time because it just takes time to book an old cargo. The NIFI has been relatively flatlined for weeks. There was a marginal uptick here. Um, if we look specifically at the China to US West Coast in this week. But what I am much more interested in here is the spread between what is quoted and then the difference to what we see on the NiFi. Because the last few weeks we saw a massive gap open up between what was quoted and what was then actually paid. That gap has now completely disappeared. And the reason I'm bringing this one up is it's not the same magnitude, it's not as large, but the trend of it, the feeling of it is the same as what we saw late May, early June this year. Remember, that is when we got the pause on China tariffs, and we saw this massive spike in spot rates. But it evaporated just as rapidly. And what we saw there was a sudden opening of a gap between the quoted and the actual paid rates, where the quoted rate turns out suddenly to grow much faster than what's being paid. Which to me is a market indication that the market is somewhat being oversold. There's an attempt to try to increase rates on the basis of a physical reality that's not quite as strong as what the quoted rates looks seem to indicate. That appears we've been going through the same thing here over the last maybe three weeks. Not to the same degree, mind you, as we saw in May and U. A little bit the same phenomenon. It appears that there was a strong push trying to get some of these rate increases through. Timing-wise, it would make sense because if we were to have a peak before Golden Week, this would be it. This would be the beginning of September. It would make all the sense in the world. But it appears that peak has not really happened.
SPEAKER_01Does it give any indication of where the rates might kind of settle as we approach Golden Week?
SPEAKER_02No. And here's the concerning part as we are approaching Golden Week, unless the carriers take more action, this could go down a lot further. There's a couple of data points that become interesting in that context. One is on the demand, one is on the supply side. Of course, as we all know, solid demand data are always lacked. I mean, you would either look at, for example, CTS, which is based on loaded dates, or you would look at, it could be, for example, like years of data mine data, but that's based on arrival in the US, and it's really at the booking stage this is interesting. But you have uh companies, you have, for example, Vision out there that are providing indications of China to US bookings. It's not the entirety of the market, but at least they have a sampling of some of the bookings data out there. And what they have been seeing here in the first week of September is a 26% decline in China to US bookings. And by the way, they also saw an 18% drop on the backhaul from US back to China, but a 26% decline on the headhold in the first week of September, in what one could have hoped was a last rally of a boom before Cold Rule. This is the exact opposite. So demand is basically in freefall, at least based on the data and numbers that we can see out there. With that in mind, it is no surprise that this rally in the quota spot rates was also extremely short-lived. But of course, if demand drops, so should capacity, if you are to at least underpin the rates and prevent them from dropping. And if we look on the capacity side, the carriers are still clear blanking savings. Later example was this morning. We had MSC announcing another five blank savings on the Pacific. But this is not enough. There was a good analysis come out from Sea Intelligence here over the weekend. And despite a lot more blank sales have been announced the last couple of weeks, we are now at a point where roughly 14% have been pulled out of the Pacific, 17% out of Asia and Europe. On Asia and Europe, this is basically in line with what we seasonally could expect on the Pacific. Well, to the East Coast, it's somewhat in line, but to the West Coast, it's not really enough even to match seasonal downturn. And we are not even seeing normal seasonal downturn. We are seeing a collapse in demand. So if we look at the numbers as they are right now, if we look at the carriers deployment as they are right now, and the fact that Golden Week is still eight, nine days ahead of us, we need to see a lot more capacity management from the market. If not, then there is not really any saying how low these rates can go. Well, there is, because if they do go down to cash negative or something to that effect, the carriers will take swift action. We will see more blank sailings. This is at least what we have seen over the past five years. The carriers have become fairly good at to dispel any myths out there. Blank sailings, there are no indications when I run the analysis that blank sailings have ever been successful in increasing rates. But it does appear blank sailings have a role to play in trying to prevent a complete collapse in swabways. We've seen that on a few occasions. So my expectation would be that the carriers will do that as well. At least that's been their way of operating the last five years. Will again a caveat. Just because this is how they have acted the last five years, we should not forget that the period prior to that, the carrier's own self-discipline was something that you had to look very long and hard to find when the market was going down. But for now, my money would be on a substantially higher amount of blank sailings as we see basically a collapse in demand on the Pacific unfold. And that would be really bad once we get into the start of October.
SPEAKER_01I'd like to actually go back to what you were saying about blank sailings not necessarily impacting the rate very much. It's a bit contrary to what I've always believed or heard. Could you explain a little bit more your thinking there?
SPEAKER_02I'm not saying it's not impacting the rate, but but here's the thing. I mean, this was especially the uh when you were at the heydays here in 2002, late 2001, 2002, 21, 22, sorry. And when rates went absolutely through the roof. There were a lot of uh, let's call them relatively angry shippers out there that looked at blank sailings and said, well, carriers are blanking sailings to jack up rates. And the truth is, yes, there were blank sailings when the rates were that high. But the whole argumentation around blank sailings usually tends to get derailed because it's a term that's been used for two very, very different reasons. Blank sailing basically just means it's a planned sailing that didn't happen, but we need to understand the reason for that blank sailing. Why did the ship not sail? During the heydays at these $10,000, $15,000,000, $20,000 rates, when you had blank sailings, it was quite literally because there were no ships. Who would not love to sail a ship if I can sail at $15,000 a box? Everybody would like to do that. Sailings were simply blank because the ships were tied up in queues outside Los Angeles, for example. Whereas if you look in the beginning of the pandemic when demand fell through the floor from one day to the next, the carriers were swiftly taking capacity out. Rates still went down, but they did not collapse, like we saw during the financial crisis, for example. So when we talk blank sailings, are they blanked because the carriers choose to blanket and remove the vessel they actually do have, or are they blanked because physically there is no ship? And where we saw rates go up, it was because physically the ships were not there. Where we saw the carriers take action and deliberately blank, that is usually when the ships are not full. And I have not seen anything in the data to suggest that that has ever been successful at raising rates, but it has prevented, in some cases, a complete collapse when otherwise you would be sailing on hand-fold ships. And it shouldn't really be all that controversial. I mean, blanking sailings, that's what carriers always do after Golden Week. They always do it after Chinese New Year. Because if demand drops 30%, why not remove 30% of capacity? It would be silly otherwise.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But it's a little strange to be seeing it so early before Golden Week, then.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, it it it definitely has come early, peak season, peaked early on Asia Europe, which is why we're already getting into Slack. And of course, the Pacific is now very much in the throes of the uh fallout from the trade war. And when we say fallout for the trade war, I I want to flag one thing that I think everybody seems to have forgotten, at least it has been buried under the deluge of other tariff news in recent weeks. But let's not forget there is not an agreement yet between US and China. There is a second pause. But the second pause was 90 days. It expires November 10th. That's just seven weeks from now. So barring anything else, in seven weeks from now, the trade war with China goes full on again. Right now, you still have very high tariffs, especially for certain commodities. In some cases, you're talking 40 to 50 percent plus. But if the trade war goes full on, this is gonna get a lot worse. So that is very much still on the horizon.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and we could even see news prior to seven weeks from now, given how everything has played out so far. Oh, yes. All right. Well, good to keep an eye on. We'll obviously uh report as things happen there. Let's talk a little bit about sustainability. We have the MEPC meeting coming up soon. Um, are there any reports that have been released recently? What's the general consensus on sentiment, you know, ahead of that meeting?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Several things. First of all, I mean, if you look at the container carriers, the main ones, they're still very much gung-ho on their drive for decarbonization. The latest one we saw was ONE came out with their new um sustainability report. Basically tracking, well, they're down 63% on uh emissions compared to the baseline in 2008. You might say, well, why do we compare to 2008? But that's actually some of the old baselines that were put in place uh with it, what's called uh scope one emissions. Their target there is 70% by 2030. So they're actually tracking very, very nicely. There's a lot of other target measures out there, but I think the important part, I mean, O and E is very clear, they're not wavering from their stance. They're still planning to decarbonize by 2050. Some other carriers are slightly more bullish. I mean, you still have worse than Harpa Game, for example, 2040. But the challenge, as you also correctly mentioned, is the MEPC meeting coming up. And what we have seen also in re the recent week is that there are more voices out there coming out in favor of not adopting it or at least postponing the implementation. You had a host of uh mainly tanker and motor owners uh located with large parts of ships from Greece, also advocating that no, no, this should not happen now. But I think there are two things to keep in mind here. This is politics at work. I mean, the meeting is three, three and a half weeks from now. So, of course, everybody is out now lobbying for their point of view. And you will hear voices also know this shouldn't happen. That's part of the political process. That doesn't necessarily mean that the ones that grab the most headlines are also the ones gaining the most traction. Uh that remains to be seen. The other thing to keep in mind is the way this industry tends to act. Let me just use one example: the low sulfur fuel. When we got the low sulfur fuel rules January 1st, 2020, this had been known for years that it would be coming. Yet when we got to 2019, less than 12 months, then all of a sudden there were very strong lobbying groups, lots of shipping lines and ship owners that were saying, Oh, we don't have time for this. We cannot do this, this is going to be too expensive. By the way, we are not prepared, despite having years to prepare. So at that point, there was also a very, very strong lobbying effort to postpone the low-sulpha rules. But despite that strong lobbying work and a lot of headlines, it was not postponed. It did go into effect as planned on January 1st, 25. So for now, it would appear that we might still get the uh net zero framework adopted here during the MEPC meeting. Will it be adopted exactly the way it was uh looking back in April? I mean, we can back to this is politics. Realistically, these things always tend to get amended in some way, shape, or form. So that remains to be seen. But for now, at least if you're on the bandwagon thinking that it's a good thing to over time decarbonize shipping, then we should at least think that, well, we should be on track and this is likely to happen. Whereas with everything else, it's not necessarily a given. But all of this, long-winded talk simply to say just because there are the opposing views that seems to be gathering more headlines in terms of this, that does not necessarily equate to that meaning that it's gonna be a no-book.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, and what would you say the impact to importers would be should this legislation pass? Like what might they expect?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I don't have a good number off the top of my head to to start off with. This goes into effect then from 2028. So it's not gonna impact their budgets in 26 and 27 to start with. Yeah. And then it's a matter of sitting down. And and even if we could put numbers on, I think that is premature. If this gets adopted uh at the MEPC meeting, I would certainly not be surprised if part of that also means changing some of the formulas and mechanisms being used. So if it gets adopted, we should revert back, and then maybe a week or two after we had a chance to run through the numbers, then it would begin to be relevant and say what would the potential cost impact here be.
SPEAKER_01Okay. All right. Well, we'll keep an eye on that. The last thing that we had on the docket for today was talking about CMA's acquisition of Freightliner. So that is the largest intermodal freight rail operator in the UK. So we're seeing some consolidation there. Is that out of the ordinary?
SPEAKER_02I wouldn't necessarily say it's out of the ordinary. It's potentially a nice strengthening of CMA's business up in the UK on the logistics side. Of course, uh good for them. It goes in line with this long undercurrent of continuing consolidation, especially in the logistics space, both by carriers and by other logistics operators. It continues to happen. It will continue to happen for a long time going forward. And of course, the logistics space is, at least from a global perspective, still a very, very fragmented space. So there is a lot of consolidation opportunities out there. That is as opposed to the carriers, especially for the large global carriers. There are very, very few of them left, which also means that any consolidation within the top 10, by now, tends to be an extraordinarily rare occurrence, which is probably also why it has gathered a few uh headlines here and there that it would appear that potentially there's a process underway to uh sell Zim or sell parts of Zim. I mean that would always gather interest because it is so rare that you now have some of the top 10. Would I necessarily place a lot of trust that this is gonna happen anytime soon? Not necessarily. It's probably gonna be a long and protracted affair if there is a large share to be sold. Secondly, uh uh at least I think a lot of the listeners would have seen that as well. There has been at least headlines out there in terms of, well, maybe Mursk is gonna buy them. I would put this in the bucket that whenever somebody is for sale out there, there's always the headline saying maybe Mursk is gonna buy them. That seems to be Mursk's role in life these days, to be to be that powerful. That being said, anybody who's looking to offload major shares in a large line of companies would of course logically go to who might buy as be and ask them. So I cannot rule out they have been asked. So do we know for sure that they are for sale? I'm not necessarily sure. Will Musk buy them? I would be highly surprised if something like that uh would happen. To add a little bit to that, I think it might be somewhat challenging, at least for some of the large multinational carriers, to buy a large share in a company like Zim. And this is not to be politically controversial at all, it's just a matter of looking at the reality out there. Of course, it is not a secret that there is a huge political movement around the whole Israel-Gaza affair, with proponents and detractors on both sides of that issue as well. The problem here is any, say, large global carrier that acquires, let's say, a majority stake in ZIM. You can argue rationally until you're blue in the face that this is just business. You have four different ships, you have nothing to do with Israel. But in a political context, which is very much an emotional context right now, it would be very hard to avoid that kind of backlash. Then, of course, the calculation should be that's fine, you might be able to live with it, or would you risk this having such negative ramifications that you're better off not dealing with it? That, of course, is not an ideal situation if you're only looking at this through a business prism. But this one in particular, I'm sorry, but there are repercussions that lie in the emotional spectrum outside the business that would have to be taken into that equation as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, it's interesting uh thoughts there. I think it seems like there's a lot of speculation in general. Like, are they even for sale? But it's uh an interesting conversation to have to talk about the details of it. Anything else you want to add on any topics today, Lars?
SPEAKER_02No, I mean, um just to add, I mean, uh it's interesting. Now we're talking Zim. It's only a couple of weeks ago we were talking HMM as well over over in Korea.
SPEAKER_01Are there any updates there that you're aware of?
SPEAKER_02Not that I'm aware of. Nope, not at all. I mean, you might even sit in here in Korea, but nope, no updates that I'm aware of.
SPEAKER_01I guess it's a slow-moving process anyway, so we wouldn't really expect anything.
SPEAKER_02It likely would be, and given what happened the last time where Hapagloid was cut out of the process, I would be surprised if this becomes anything other than an internal Korean affair in terms of uh changing ownership of uh HMM.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, I think that's everything then for today's episode. Uh, if you have not already subscribed, be sure to subscribe on Apple Music, Spotify, or to our YouTube channel. And until then, I hope everyone has an awesome week and we'll be back on next Monday. Bye everyone. Bye everyone.